Is It Better to Repair or Replace My Deck?

Your deck provides an outdoor oasis where you can enjoy quiet moments, host memorable gatherings, and create delicious food for family and friends. When it becomes damaged or worn, deciding whether to repair or replace it can be tough. 

Wood decks last 15-20 years when they are well maintained and protected from moisture intrusion. Composite decking can last 25 years or more with regular upkeep. Like any other element of your exterior, your deck is exposed to weather 24/7, and as it gets older, issues may pop up. Read on to discover when it’s best to repair or replace your decking. 

Evaluate Features That Influence Deck Repair vs. Replacement 

Know Your Deck’s Lifespan and Makeup

Depending on the lifespan of the material your deck is made of (composite or wood), as it ages, issues may appear such as wood rot due to moisture damage, broken boards, wobbly rails, and unsafe stairs. 

Avoid the possibility of accidents by reaching out to a contractor (like us!) to inspect your deck to help determine the extent of the damage and the best remedy. If your deck is near the end of its lifespan, a new deck is a great option as it will give your years of enjoyment. But if your deck is on the newer side and structurally sound, repairing it may be the best option.

Assess Your Deck’s Various Parts 

Give your deck a thorough inspection or ask a contractor to assess your decking to ensure you make an informed decision about repairs vs. replacement. 

Deck Surface

The boards that make up your deck’s surface are constantly in contact with the Kansas City area’s weather. UV rays may make them fade and moisture may cause them to rot. Over time, the integrity of your deck’s structure may become compromised if issues like wood rot go unaddressed. Here are some issues to check on your deck surface:

• Visible damage such as cracking, warping and rot (these are often cause for deck replacement)
• Splintering, scratching, and discoloration (these are causes for deck repairs)

If your deck’s surface is damaged, its supporting features may fail, which calls for a deck replacement. 

Deck Railing 

Your deck’s railing is a vital safety feature that needs to be in excellent shape to ensure the protection of you and your guests. If railing gets loose, it can cause accidents. When moisture penetrates deck railing, it becomes unsecure and wobbly. Minor decking issues may be repaired, but if railing problems go unattended and get worse, you’ll likely need to replace your deck.  

Beams and Joists

Your deck’s wood beams and joists are installed horizontally beneath your decking’s surface to support it—and they’re vital. If wood isn’t well sealed, moisture may penetrate and cause damage over the years. If you catch issues when they are small, it’s possible to repair them. But if your beams and joists are weak due to extensive water damage and rot, it’s time for a deck replacement. 

Ledger Board Issues 

The most common deck failure occurs when a deck pulls away from the house and collapses. This happens when the ledger board wasn’t properly attached to your home during its installation. If your ledger board decays, it can impact deck safety as well. Older decks may not meet today’s safety standards, making them more vulnerable. In contrast, today’s decking materials include brackets that extend into your home, which provide greater safety and security. A deck replacement is often the best solution to faulty ledger board problems. 

Fascia

Your fascia board wraps around your deck’s perimeter just below your deck boards. If it becomes discolored, that’s a signal water has penetrated it and is damaging it. Replacing your fascia is an option if the moisture issue is contained. 

Flashing 

If flashing is damaged but the rest of your deck is not, replacing it is a smart option to keep moisture away from infiltrating your deck. If you find additional water damage, a deck replacement may be a safer option to consider. 

Deck Posts

Vertical posts keep your deck in place above the ground. Moisture can penetrate at the base of your posts and where the beams attach to them. The greater the water damage, the greater the possibility that your best option is a deck replacement to ensure your safety. 

Weigh the Cost of Repairs vs. Replacement 

When considering the cost of deck repairs vs. replacement, keep in mind how the solution you choose will set you up for the future. Will your decision to repair your deck mean you’ll still need to replace it in the next few years? If you’re putting money into your deck due to several repair needs, would it be smarter to just pay once and have a new, custom deck installed? 

Minor issues can be repaired easily, but if multiple deck problems have stacked up, it may be smart to replace rather than repair your decking. A new deck ensures your safety and gives you the function your desire for years to come.  

Is replacing just your deck boards an option? 

Your subframe will need to be thoroughly inspected to ensure there is no rot, decay, or weakening due to aging before considering adding new boards onto it. It would be dangerous to put brand new boards on a failing subframe. 

Enhance Your Lifestyle with a Stunning New Deck Design

Don’t risk the possibility of an accident if your decking is old or damaged. Get a gorgeous new custom deck installed by our experienced team. Imagine the beauty of redesigning your deck into a more up-to-date outdoor space to enjoy! 

At Safe Harbor, we install long-lasting composite decking or traditional wood decking so you can get the best solution for your long-term needs. We ensure your deck is beautiful, low maintenance, and functional. Learn more about how our custom deck installation services can create the ideal space for you to entertain family and friends.