A snow-covered house with white siding and partial stone facade.

Metal Roof Installation: Should Old Shingles Be Removed Before New Installation?

metal-roof-installation-should-old-shingles-be-removed-before-new-installation_6068994d34fcd

Reroofing is the practice that involves installing a new roof over an existing one. Some roofers recommend this practice to homeowners who are planning on switching from an asphalt shingle roof. But is this a good idea? 

Why Do Some Roofers Practice Reroofing?

The main objective of reroofing, as opposed to the standard practice of stripping the old roof before installation, is to save on removal and disposal costs. Reroofing is also done when roof replacement needs to be done in the shortest time possible.

It’s important to note that in most cases, the said pros are outweighed by its cons. Reroofing skips fundamental steps, such as structural repairs. If the roof has hidden issues, such as damage from trapped moisture, it won’t be addressed during installation. It also doubles the weight of the roof if you’re replacing it with the same type of roofing material. This can be a problem if the support structure isn’t built to carry such weight. The fasteners will likewise be doubled, which can compromise roofing integrity.

Reroofing With Metal

Some roofing contractors recommend reroofing with standing seam metal because the total roof weight is but a fraction of a standard asphalt shingle roof, which helps preserve the roofing integrity. 

However, before you decide on reroofing with a metal roof, you have to keep in mind that there are specific conditions that make reroofing with a metal roof safe. For instance, decking isn’t suitable for a third replacement, regardless of condition, so a third installation with the same decking won’t be structurally sound. Roofing that obviously requires repair will, of course, need to be stripped.

Work With a Certified Contractor

If you are considering reroofing instead of a “clean” installation, then you need to work with experienced and certified roofing contractors. They will be responsible for assessing the roof’s condition. You have to anticipate the possibility that your roofing contractor will deem your roof unsuitable for reroofing and that pushing through with it can result in premature roofing failure.

Safe Harbor Exteriors is your leading provider of metal and wood shake roof systems. Give us a call at (913) 553-3620, or fill out our contact form. We serve customers in Shawnee, KS, and nearby areas in Kansas City.

Get a Free Estimate

Latest Blog Posts

If woodpeckers are making themselves at home in your siding, drilling holes to create a place to nest or gather insects for their next meal, your home’s protective layer is now vulnerable to costly moisture damage. ..

essential-features-of-a-secure-front-door.webp

Choosing the right material is one of the most significant decisions homeowners face during a window replacement project...

durable-window-frame-material.webp

When homeowners ask us about upgrading their windows, one of the most common questions we hear is, “Are triple-pane windows worth the extra cost...

triple-pane-windows-Kansas-City.webp

Reviews

We talked to multiple companies while deciding who to use for the exterior of our home. Safe Harbor was transparent, fast, and offered James Hardie siding compared to all the other companies only offering vinyl. Safe Harbor was much more affordable than many of the other companies, who just wanted as much money as possible. We are extremely happy with our siding, soffit, fascia, flashing, gutters, windows and the guarantee that comes with their work. If there was any more work to be performed, without a doubt, we would chose safe Harbor again.

James W.

Safe Harbor installed James Hardie siding, soffits, and gutters. The install was meticulous and our home was left cleaner than when the company showed up. The level of detail in the install was beyond expectation! We are so pleased with the quality of the work and the professionalism of the install team!

Carolyn P.
The Google "G" logo.
5.0
Rating
The Facebook "F" logo.
4.9
Rating
The GuildQuality logo.
4.9
Rating
A badge for a Better Business Bureau (BBB) Accredited Business.
A+
Rating

Trusted Brands & Partners

An "Elite Preferred" badge from James Hardie.
The logo for Fiberon.
The logo badge for a GAF Master Elite Gold certified contractor.
A "Master Shingle Applicator" logo badge from CertainTeed.
A logo badge for an award for service excellence from GuildMaster.
The logo for Pella.
The logo for ProVia.
The logo for Marvin.
The RainDrop Pro Gutter Guard logo.
The EZ Gutter Guards logo.
The logo for DECRA Metal Roofing.
The logo for DaVinci Roofscapes.
The Owens Corning logo.
The CertainTeed logo.

Contact Us

A house with new siding and roofing with the Safe Harbor Exteriors logo superimposed on the left side.

Address
11009 Johnson Dr.
Shawnee, KS 66203
Get Directions
© 2025 Safe Harbor Exteriors. All Rights Reserved